Overview Logo
Article Main Image

Many reasons for Israel to hate the old men of Hamas, but hard to see how Doha strike helps plight of hostages

Sky News

United Kingdom

Tuesday, September 9


Alternative Takes

The World's Current Take

International Condemnation and Diplomatic Reactions

Trump Administration Response and US Position


The Israeli airstrike on the Qatari capital Doha is a step change in the way they tackle their enemies, but only the latest in a series of them.

In the past, Israel used stealthier means to dispatch its foes. Plausible deniability was preferable.

October 7 changed everything, the Israelis say.

So when they came for Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh in 2024 in the Iranian capital of Tehran, they didn't bother with anything as subtle as poison or strangulation - they blew him up with an airstrike instead.

Now it's launched another one , this time not on a city in a country that's hostile to Israel, but one it has relations with, to the horror of the region and massive diplomatic fallout.

You might assume the targets were high value, a clear and present threat to Israel, to justify all that. Not exactly.

There are plenty of reasons for Israelis to hate the old men of Hamas, whom they appear to have targeted. In the past, some of them were instrumental in organising terrorist attacks that killed many innocent women and children.

Smoke rising in aftermath of airstrike in Doha by Israel on Hamas leaders Pic: Reuters
Image: Smoke rising in aftermath of airstrike in Doha by Israel on Hamas leaders Pic: Reuters

They will have cheered on the 7 October atrocities, but so far as we know, they were not its primary masterminds.

Hamas' Doha office

In 2011, the US government persuaded the Qataris to let Hamas open a political office in Doha, and the Israelis approved of the idea.

Everyone wanted an address to negotiate with and funnel millions of dollars through to Gaza.

In the words of one Israeli official:"We believe that better conditions in Gaza would lessen the incentive of Hamas and the population to go again to a war. So in a way, it is helping the deterrence."

Critics of Benjamin Netanyahu said he was deliberately strengthening one wing of Palestinian politics as part of a cynical policy of divide and rule.

For whatever reason, Israel acquiesced fully in the Hamas political office being set up in Doha. It was staffed with some of the veterans of its cause who seem to have been on the target list in this strike.

When I interviewed Khaled Meshaal in Doha in October 2023 , he was determined and dogmatic, but seemed at one stage removed.

He was no longer the ideological godfather of the movement, he clearly had been when I first met him in Damascus in 2017.

Former Hamas leader, Khalid Meshaal Pic: Reuters
Image: Former Hamas leader, Khalid Meshaal Pic: Reuters

The hard men of Gaza - Yahya Sinwar, Abu Obeida, Muhammad Deif - were in control now, much more than those languishing in exile.

Hard to see how strikes help hostages in Gaza

Mr Netanyahu will have had his reasons for today's strikes.

He has almost certainly been waiting for another chance to kill Meshaal after his first attempt failed so spectacularly.

In 1997, he sent Mossad agents to pour a lethal poison into his ear in the Jordanian capital, Amman.

They botched the job, and King Hussein told then-US president Bill Clinton to order the Israeli leader to hand over an antidote that saved him.

Initial reports suggest the wily Meshaal escaped the latest attempt on his life, too.

But the men killed and targeted today were, for all their faults, the people Israel was indirectly talking to try to negotiate the return of their hostages.

It is hard to see how this helps their plight now.

Get the full experience in the app

Scroll the Globe, Pick a Country, See their News

International stories that aren't found anywhere else.

Global News, Local Perspective

50 countries, 150 news sites, 500 articles a day.

Don’t Miss what Gets Missed

Explore international stories overlooked by American media.

Unfiltered, Uncensored, Unbiased

Articles are translated to English so you get a unique view into their world.

Apple App Store Badge